Müzakirə:Mehmet Murat İldan

Vikipediya, açıq ensiklopediya - ویکیپدیا ، آچیق انسایکلوپدیا

[redaktə / تحریر] Renewed call for deletion

Take a look at en:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehmet Murat İldan. This article is now deleted from almost every wikipedia, due to the aggressive selfpromotion. en:User:Orland / no:Bruker:Orland (admin on no:) --80.232.34.55 19:27, 25 Yanvar 2007 (UTC)

Bu barede en genis muzakirelerin getdiyi en:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehmet Murat İldan sehifesinde alinan qerara esasen meqalenin silinmesi nezere alina biler. --TimBitsتِمبِتس 16:56, 26 Yanvar 2007 (UTC)


  • COMMENT This is nothing to do with racism at all. To be honest, I have not seen any racism or prejudice against Turks in the discussions. But there is a simple confusion about the notability criteria. One of the Wikipedia criteria is "The person has been a primary subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the person." The writer in question has 10 books published in Turkey and it can easily be verified from many independent sources. Another criteria is this: "Published authors, editors and photographers who received multiple independent reviews of or awards for their work." So the writer Mehmet Murat İldan has awards as well. May be I should say something in Turkish as well. Olayın ırkçılıkla bir ilgisi yok, ya da Türklere karşı bir hareket falan yok. Sadece bu yazarın notable olmadığı söyleniyor ki bu doğru değil, Türkiye'de 10 tane kitabı yayınlanmış. Peki Azeriler için bu yazar bir önem taşır mı? Neden taşımasın. Türkler Azeri yazarları merak ediyor, Azeriler de Türk yazarları. Ayrıca biz Azeri Tvsini sıkça seyrediyoruz ve anlıyoruz, bir Azeri de Türkçeyi eminim ki anlayabiliyor... Keşke bu yazıyı öz dilimiz olan Azericede yazabilseydim, ama alfabelerde farklılıklar olmuş epeyce... iyi akşamlar. Tagorgora.


Müzakirə olunduğu üçün sil şablonunu götürdüm.--A_M_D 10:46, 30 Yanvar 2007 (UTC)


Article has now been delete in en:, de:, fr: and 15-20 other languages. Some people has asked if this is some kind of vendetta. Of course, it is not personal; I'm a librarian, litarary critic and lover of books myself; elsewhere I've stated my efforts to promote literatur from the Middle East in Norway. My actions are only taken to prove that we can't tolerate this kind of spamming towards wp. no:User:Orland / en:User:Orland. --89.10.33.253 08:34, 3 Fevral 2007 (UTC)

After a debate, Finnish Wikipedia has decided to keep the article about Mehmet Murat Ildan. References checking is currently ongoing and some confirmations have already been received regarding Mr. Ildan's publications.

Ildan article may be self-promotion. But the cleansing campaign does not seem to be without political motives either. 83.145.205.27 19:43, 10 Mart 2007 (UTC)