विकिपीडिया:निर्वाचित लेख उम्मीदवार
विकिपीडिया, एक मुक्त ज्ञानकोष से
यह पृष्ठ किसी और भाषा में लिखा गया है। आप इसका अनुवाद करके विकिपीडिया की मदद कर सकते हैं।
निर्वाचित लेख
निर्वाचित लेख आवश्यकताएं (वार्ता) • निर्वाचित लेख उम्मीदवार (वार्ता) • मुखपृष्ठ में निर्वाचित लेख (वार्ता) • निर्वाचित लेख परख (वार्ता)
निर्वाचित लेख उम्मीदवार यह तालिका एक विकिपीडिया में निर्वाचित लेख का उम्मीदवारों का तालिका है। To nominate an article, add {{subst:नया निर्वाचित लेख प्रस्ताव|The name of the article you are nominating|~~~~|your comments}}. Before becoming featured, an article must reach the निर्वाचित लेख आवश्यकताएं. It is therefore you may add comments/ideas/suggestions (on how to improve the article) to the current nominations, starting with *'''समार्थन''' or *'''विरुद्ध''' if desired. |
[संपादित करें] भारत
- (प्रस्तावक: Wolf १५:१३, १३ जनवरी २००७ (UTC))
Despite this article is already on the front page, it is not yet officially featured. What is still expected from this article:
- The introduction' needs to be improved; please see en:WP:LEAD
- Footnotes need to be added. These are very necessary. Please look at en:Wikipedia:Footnotes.
- References need to be added. These are very necessary. Please look at en:WP:HARV.
- A lot of the links are red, these will have to be linked to pages.
- It is not balanced; some of the sections are very small, and some of them are very large.
- The Hindi text needs to be cleaned up, for example sometimes there is |, sometimes there is ।.
- Too many redlinks. Deeptrivia २३:३८, ११ मार्च २००७ (UTC)
-
- I've never thought redlinks were much of a problem. An article should stand on its own quality. The redlinks typically serve to mark articles that the reader can contribute, and I think that's fine for a growing project. - टैक्सवाला १५:४३, १२ मार्च २००७ (UTC)
-
- Haha, okay.. was just trying to make use of the situation to get the article count to increase :P Deeptrivia १५:५५, १२ मार्च २००७ (UTC)
[संपादित करें] सत्यजित राय
With a bit of tweaking, getting the red links blue, this article is ready for July the first. But I thought we could do something about the long जीवन section. Maybe, instead of using the subheading 3 for all the small sections, we could use the subheading 2 (==2==) as used on the the English version. What do you all think?
- Since nobody has replied for almost two months, I am nominating this article to featured status, and am replacing महादेवी वर्मा to सत्यजित राय on the front page.--वुल्फ़वार्ता ०८:२५, १ अगस्त २००७ (UTC)
- I support your action. --मितुल २१:२८, १ अगस्त २००७ (UTC)
[संपादित करें] रक्षाबंधन
- (प्रस्तावक: मितुल २१:२८, १ अगस्त २००७ (UTC))
- इस लेख पर काफी अच्छा काम हो चुका है। इसे हमे निर्वाचित लेख बना देना चाहिए। कृपया अपनी टिप्पणी दे। -मितुल १८:०७, २८ अगस्त २००७ (UTC)
-
- Very good work, quite a bit more complete than the English version in fact. Keep up the good work. The thing I see that jumps out right away is the short paragraphs. Anything less than three sentences isn't a fully developed idea and should either be expanded, merged with related material, or removed because it isn't important enough to justify the space. Also a couple of the images need appropriate free licenses or they need to be replaced. The first one is fine, but should carry the GFDL release of the original author. The second one has no info, the third has some sort of PD template, but it doesn't exist, so I don't know what that is, and the last one is fine. - टैक्सवाला ०२:५९, २९ अगस्त २००७ (UTC)