Disputatio:Carolus Montesquieu

E Vicipaedia

[recensere] Montesquieu in Latin

I of course don't add names to Index philosophorum unless I have a source (unfortunately I wrote that page before there was a <ref>-tag, so I didn't note anything). Looking at WorldCat again, I see no Latin name used by Montesquieu himself, but some used by others:

  • 1839 Iani Heemskerk:[1] Speciminis inauguralis. De Montesquivio.
  • 1839 Delbrück: Ad impugnandam Montesquievii sententiam de principio, unde regnorum integritas et salus petendae sint
  • 1892 Émile Durkheim [sic]: Quid Secundatus politicae scientiae instituendae contulerit

If we could find a name Montesquieu himself used, I would change the page immediately. If I wrote the page myself, I would use the name i listed in Index philosophorum. However, since neither is the case here, I leave it open to discussion. --Iustinus 22:29, 3 Septembris 2007 (UTC)

[recensere] Notes!?

  1. As is common in such dissertations, the author's Latin name is not given, but references list him as both Janus Heemskerk and Janus Heemskerk, so it's a fair bet the latter is his Latin name as it appears in the diss.