Razgovor:Mehmet Murat İldan
Izvor: Wikipedija
This article should be deleted. I who call for delete is admin on no:, no:Bruker:Orland. This article is spread to several editions of wp as a extreme self-pr without any reasonable notability.— Prethodni nepotpisani komentar napisao je 80.232.34.55 ((razgovor • doprinosi) ).
- Nisam siguran u vezi ove opaske. Ovaj IP ostavio je istu oznaku na nizu drugih Wikipedija, a na norveškoj Wikipediji i kao potpisani suradnik stavio je oznaku za brisanje. Vidim na turskoj Wikipediji, u razgovoru uz članak, da se razvila diskusija o autobiografiji, no članak čini mi se još nije predložen za brisanje. Trebalo bi vidjeti kako će se stvar odvijati na većim wikipedijama gdje možemo razumjeti o čemu je riječ.--Donatus 07:07, 24. siječanj 2007. (CET)
-
- An article about Mehmet Murat İldan is not relevant to readers in languages that he has not been translated into. And the english article is obviously lying about his reputation, as it foresees how his reputation will be in the future. Please note the intro statement "Following his epistolary novel, en:The First Sorrows of Young Werther, he is regarded as a romantic writer", when the book in question is due to be published in february this year. This is indeed prophetic skills by the article's author. When the article also states that this unpublished «The First Sorrows of Young Werther» is his magnum opus, we can easily assume that this author is not notable, yet. --en:Orland 07:56, 24 January 2007 (UTC) --no:Orland 24. jan 2007 kl. 10:57 (CET)
[uredi] Renewed call for deletion
Take a look at en:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehmet Murat İldan. This article is now deleted from almost every wikipedia, due to the aggressive selfpromotion. en:User:Orland / no:Bruker:Orland (admin on no:) --80.232.34.55 20:38, 25. siječanj 2007. (CET)
ZA Ovo je očita samopromocija. --Ante Perkovic 08:06, 27. siječanj 2007. (CET)
ZA Točno. I već je obrisan članak s mnogih Wikipedija, a na ostalima je glasovanje o tome. --Donatus 08:28, 27. siječanj 2007. (CET)