Disputatio:Subtilia

E Vicipaedia

Delenda for a month...anyone want to keep it?--Ioshus Rocchio 04:26, 8 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

Seems to have been a self-promotion, it's a small internet company. Check [1].--Ioshus Rocchio 03:18, 11 Iunii 2006 (UTC)
Although I dislike promotion when it smells after "make money fast", I like intelligent promotion.
This it what we are talking about:
Haec sunt de Subtilia pagina electronica:

'''Subtilia'''

Subtilia litterarium periodicum est, quod Latinam orationem solutam et totius auctorum orbis terrae poesim contemporaneam animadvertit, publicaturum opera artificiosa, illustrissima, exquisita.

Subtilia cum artificibus flagranter desiderat sociam navare operam, qui futuris editionibus splendidum apparatum praebeant; cumque Latinitatis expertibus linguisticam periodici integritatem custodiendam procuraturis. Editio prima apparebit postquam documenta publicanda completa erunt.

Cum Subtilia periodicum plene solutum extraorinariumque sit, non potest suis auctoribus mercedem persolvere, sed omnia illorum proprietatis iura reservaturum esse affirmat.

==Nexus externi==
* [http://www.subtilia.org Subtilia.org]

[[categoria:Litteratura]]

[[pl:Subtilia]]
[[en:Subtilia]]
  • It is in Latin, so it does not smell after "make money fast".
  • The content of the referenced page is in Latin, see http://subtilia.topworld.org/la.html
  • Ok, no other Wikipedias have a page about "Subtilia" (the en and pl are broken links). Why shouldn't we have something others don't have?
  • Does it hurt?
  • If we do not really agree with the content and if it hurts, let's make a template like "We think this content is not very relevant, however, we keep it to be able to give you this information about it's lacking relevance."
  • Anyone who does not want to read something about "Subtilia" shall not click on Subtilia. — If we ever will produce a printed version we could skip such pages ... if we had a special template.

--Roland2 08:41, 11 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

Vide Disputatio_Vicipaediae:Deletio#Promotion. --Roland2 08:44, 11 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

I am an author of Subtilia webpage and I want to take part in the discussion.
First of all, I'd like to thank you for your intelligent criticism.
In response that this wikipage could be a self-promotion, I'd answer that, of course, IT IS a self-promotion, but not to "make money fast" at all. Subtilia is not a company, subtilia is not even my dream, subtilia is almost no more, unless somebody will take care of it.
As a man totally inexperienced at something I would call "web promotion", I imagined that I would be able to promote an interesting and thought-provoking, FREE, and first I suppose Latin literary magazine, which after few months I would give to somebody more apt to do such a job than I. I was wrong and after the first unsuccessful atempt (with the Latin Wikipedia, too) I gave up. I reminded Subtilia two days ago and was astonished, that this wikipage has not been erased yet. It proves that I should be more patient. Ad rem: Anyone, who would like to be an editor of free, internet, literary, Latin magazine Subtilia, and to cooperate with me in order to develop the project, please contanct me: mlm(at)os(dot)pl and "make money fast". (I understand that what has been said above is another solicitation, but I think, that the idea of Subtilia magazine is not so bad, although done in a clumsy way).
Previous comment by 19:01, 24 Iulii 2006 Usor:87.105.64.56 


Well, Rol...I gotta hand it to you. I don't know what to do now. We have confession...are we wikimorally obliged to purge this self promotion? Put the iocus template on it? Nominate it as an article of the month, maybe for april fools day next year? I don't know...--Ioshus Rocchio 19:37, 24 Iulii 2006 (UTC)

What about nominating this article "vanity of the month"? ;-) --UV 23:05, 25 Augusti 2006 (UTC)

[recensere] versio latina iam extat?

Aperire versionem latinam non potui. Iam existat? Praeterea ultima pagina, ubi "delenda" inserui, vacua erat. Alex1011 20:54, 24 Iulii 2006 (UTC)