Discuţie Utilizator:80.36.189.123

De la Wikipedia, enciclopedia liberă

[modifică] Limba spaniolă

V-am anulat modificarea la articolul Limba spaniolă. Nu pot verifica dacă este o sursă de încredere deoarece conţinutul sitului nu este la vedere. Criteriile noastre de credibilitate a surselor sînt destul de stricte. — AdiJapan  13 iunie 2006 19:58 (EEST)

The problem with that website is that its contents is hidden, and only available to subscribers. Like many other people, I am afraid of spam email, so I am not going to subscribe. As such, I cannot check if the site qualifies as a reliable source -- check your Wikipedia or en.wp, and you will find that the criteria for a reliable source are quite tough.
As long as the site is not freely accessible I don't think it can be included in a Wikipedia article as a source. I suspect that this is yet another technique to collect email addresses, otherwise I don't see any reason not to let anyone see the lessons. — AdiJapan  14 iunie 2006 17:28 (EEST)
That's what I meant by "hidden": not online, not visible.
It's not a question about evaluating your lessons. We don't have that authority. The lessons could be brilliant. The problem is that we need to know who created those lessons, who checked them, who assumes the responsiblity for their quality, and what qualification these people have in teaching Spanish.
It doesn't matter if I like your lessons or not. The reliability of a source must be verifiable by anyone.
I suggested you read about what sources are considered reliable. Here's the link you need: en:Wikipedia:Reliable sources. You will see that your service (I cannot even call it a website) does not qualify as a reliable source. — AdiJapan  14 iunie 2006 21:09 (EEST)

To make a long story short: I cannot agree to list the link to

http://www.nueva-tierra.com/

because it is not accessible. However, I can agree to list this other link,

http://www.elistas.net/lista/esp-ing/archivo/msg/174/

on one condition: you tell me where this site states the authors of the lessons and their authority. Once you tell me where that information is available, you can insert this second link in the article Limba spaniolă. — AdiJapan  15 iunie 2006 16:23 (EEST)


Aceasta este pagina de discuţii pentru un utilizator care nu şi-a creat un cont încă, sau care nu s-a autentificat. De aceea trebuie să folosim adresa IP pentru a identifica această persoană. O adresă IP poate fi folosită în comun de mai mulţi utilizatori. Dacă sunteţi un astfel de utilizator şi credeţi că vă sunt adresate mesaje irelevante, vă rugăm să vă creaţi un cont sau să vă autentificaţi pentru a evita confuzii cu alţi utilizatori anonimi în viitor.